As a doula and certified lactation educator, one of the most common questions I get asked is: What is the best breast pump? I absolutely love that this question gets asked! It tells me that families are thinking ahead, preparing for their breastfeeding journey and looking for guidance, something I’m always happy to provide.
However, as much as I understand the desire for a simple, straightforward answer, the truth is that there’s no one-size-fits-all breast pump. I know that with all the decisions that come with the birth of a child, it’s easy to want a quick fix. But, the best pump for you depends on a few important factors, and taking the time to consider them will help you feel confident in and satisfied with your decision.
Here are some key questions to help guide your breast pump selection
Start by asking yourself two important questions:
1. What are your feeding goals?
2. Why might you want to pump?
Starting with these two questions is imperative. Understanding your goals and reasons for pumping will also help you make an informed decision. Do you hope to provide baby with milk for X amount of time to provide certain long-term health benefits? Are you pumping to create a stash of milk before returning to work? Are you trying to increase your supply? Or perhaps you need relief from engorgement or want to give a partner the opportunity to feed the baby?
For consistent pumping to build up a milk supply or create a stash, a double electric pump is typically the most efficient. However, if you’re looking to pump for occasional relief or a bottle for a date night, a manual or single electric pump might be more than enough.
3. How often do you anticipate pumping?
The frequency of your pumping sessions plays a major role in what type of pump will be best suited to your needs. If you’re planning to pump often, whether due to returning to work, creating a milk stash or providing milk for a baby with specific feeding needs, a double electric breast pump is often the best choice. These pumps are efficient, typically fast and allow for both breasts to be pumped at the same time.
On the other hand, if you expect to pump only occasionally, perhaps just for relief from engorgement or to have some milk on hand for the occasional bottle, a manual pump or a simple single electric pump can do the job without the added expense and bulk of a double electric pump.
4. Where will you pump?
The location where you’ll do most of your pumping can also influence your choice. If you’ll be pumping frequently at work or in other public spaces, you’ll likely want something that’s discreet and efficient. Many electric pumps are designed to be quiet and easy to use in private settings like a work office or while traveling. Hands-free and wearable pumps that tuck into your shirt/bra may be better for the more discreet or on-the-go environment.
If you work from home or have flexible hours, you may prefer a manual pump or a single electric pump that’s more portable and cost-effective. A double-electric can still be very, very effective in this environment as well. A hand pump can also be a great option for quick, occasional sessions and is usually lightweight and easy to pack for trips.
5. What options are available through your insurance?
Did you know that under the Affordable Care Act, most health insurance plans (with a few exceptions) must provide breastfeeding equipment, including a breast pump, at no extra cost? This is a wonderful resource, but it’s important to know what options your insurance company offers. Reach out to your provider to get a list of the pumps available to you. Many insurance plans offer a selection of high-quality electric pumps, so don’t overlook this valuable benefit.
6. What accessories are included?
Some pumps come with useful accessories that can make your pumping experience much more convenient and cost-effective. When selecting a pump, take note of what’s included in the package. Common accessories include storage bags for milk, extra bottles, different size flanges (*important for comfort and efficiency), and a carrying bag for easy transport.
These accessories can add extra value to your purchase, so be sure to keep an eye out for packages that include everything you might need.
Now that you've asked and answered these questions for yourself, here's a quick rundown on...
The main types of breast pumps with pros & cons...
1. Manual Breast Pump:
A manual pump requires you to use your hand to create suction, making it the most affordable option.
Pros:
- Inexpensive and portable
- Quiet, discreet and simple to use
- Great for occasional use or for relief from engorgement
- No need for electricity or batteries
- No tubes/cords
Cons:
- Can be tiring and time-consuming for frequent use
- Slower than electric pumps
- Not ideal for building a milk stash or frequent pumping sessions
2. Double Electric Breast Pump:
A double electric pump works automatically and allows you to pump both breasts at the same time, making it the best choice for frequent use.
Pros:
- Fast and efficient for frequent pumping
- Allows for both breasts to be pumped at once, cutting down on time
- Typically more powerful and consistent suction compared to single electric pumps
- Great for creating a milk stash, maintaining milk supply or pumping regularly at work
Cons:
- Can be more expensive and bulky
- Requires tubes/cords
- Requires electricity or battery power
- Can be loud, though many models are quieter than they used to be
3. Wearable or Hands-Free Breast Pump:
Wearable pumps are designed to fit inside your bra, allowing for hands-free pumping while you move around.
Pros:
- Super convenient: can pump while doing other tasks
- Portable and discreet: ideal for pumping while out & about or at work
- Quiet and comfortable, with no tubes/cords
- No need to sit still or be attached to a wall outlet
Cons:
- Can be more expensive than other pumps
- May not be as efficient or powerful as double electric pumps
- Some models may have a smaller milk capacity, meaning you may need to pump more often
- May be bulky to tuck into bra
Bonus: Consider Friends’ and Family’s Recommendations
Hearing from others can be a great way to narrow down your options. While personal experiences vary, asking friends and family members about their favorite pumps can offer helpful insights. Why did they like or dislike a particular pump? Some people find that certain brands work better for them based on the way they pump or their breast shape. Read some online reviews as well to see how others felt about their chosen models.
At the end of the day, whatever pump you choose, know that you’ve made the best decision for yourself with the information you have. Remember, there’s no need for perfection here: breastfeeding and pumping are personal journeys, and each family’s experience will look a little different. The key is to select a pump that supports your lifestyle, comfort and goals.
If you’re ever uncertain, don’t hesitate to reach out to a lactation consultant (NHlactation.com) or doula for further guidance. They can help you navigate the options and ensure you’re well-prepared for your breastfeeding journey.
Happy pumping!










